Free U.S. shipping over $36USDA Certified OrganicMade in the USA4 ingredients. No compromises.30-day money-back guaranteeFree U.S. shipping over $36USDA Certified OrganicMade in the USA4 ingredients. No compromises.30-day money-back guaranteeFree U.S. shipping over $36USDA Certified OrganicMade in the USA4 ingredients. No compromises.30-day money-back guarantee
Home/Compare/Numbrrrz vs Blistex
Honest comparison

Numbrrrz vs Blistex.

A transparent look at how Numbrrrz compares to Blistex.

Side-by-side

The full comparison.

Disclosure: published by Numbrrrz. We strive for accuracy but acknowledge our perspective as a competing brand.

Feature
NumbrrrzNumbrrrz
Blistex
Contains menthol/camphorNoYes — in most formulas
Contains siliconesNoYes (dimethicone)
Ingredient count415-25
Chemical sunscreen filtersNoYes (in SPF varieties)
Creates dependencyNo — heals over timeYes — irritants drive reapplication
Organic ingredientsYesNo
Preservatives usedVitamin E (natural antioxidant)Methylparaben, propylparaben, BHT (varies by product)
Available varieties / scentsFocused single formula — one product, perfectedDozens of varieties (medicated, SPF, flavored, etc.)
Allergen riskVery low — 4 non-allergenic ingredientsHigher — fragrances, dyes, menthol, and parabens are common sensitizers
Cruelty-free statusYes — cruelty-freeBlistex does not have Leaping Bunny certification and has unclear animal testing policies

Who Owns Blistex?

Independent

Blistex Inc. -- Lip Care

Why Numbrrrz wins

What sets us apart.

Numbrrrz — 4 organic ingredients

No dimethicone (silicone) or cyclomethicone

No camphor, menthol, or phenol that irritate and create dependency

No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives

No SPF chemicals (oxybenzone, octinoxate, etc.)

Clean 4-ingredient formula vs. Blistex's 15-25 ingredient lists

No medicated 'tingle' — actual healing ingredients instead

The switch

Why switch to Numbrrrz.

Blistex markets itself as a medicated lip care solution, but the medication is the problem. Their formulas are loaded with menthol, camphor, and other irritants that create the same dependency cycle as Carmex. The 'medicated tingle' is actually your lips being irritated, which causes dryness that makes you need to reapply. Add in dimethicone (silicone), artificial flavors, chemical sunscreen filters, and 20+ other ingredients, and you have a product that is treating symptoms it is creating. Numbrrrz takes a radically different approach — four organic ingredients that actually heal and strengthen lip tissue over time. Blistex Medicated Lip Balm lists three active ingredients: dimethicone 2.0%, menthol 0.6%, and camphor 0.5%. The inactive ingredients read like a chemistry textbook: cetyl alcohol, cyclomethicone, FD&C Red 40 Aluminum Lake, flavors, lanolin, methylparaben, mineral oil, myristyl myristate, paraffin, petrolatum, polyphenylmethylsiloxane 556, propylparaben, saccharin, sorbitan oleate, and theobroma cacao seed butter. That is over 20 ingredients, including two parabens (preservatives flagged as potential endocrine disruptors), petroleum derivatives, artificial dyes, and synthetic fragrances. By contrast, Numbrrrz gives you Organic Coconut Oil, Organic Jojoba Oil, Organic Beeswax, and Vitamin E. That is it. Blistex has carved a niche by positioning itself as the go-to brand for people with chronically dry or damaged lips. There is an irony there: many of those chronic lip issues are perpetuated by the very irritants in medicated formulas. Blistex is not the villain in some conspiracy — they are just following a decades-old pharmaceutical approach that prioritizes symptom relief over root cause resolution. If you want to actually resolve chronic lip dryness rather than manage it indefinitely, trading medicated irritants for organic nourishment is the way forward. It takes about a week to adjust, and the results speak for themselves.

Get Your Free Ingredient Safety Report

Enter your email and we'll send you a personalized breakdown of the most common harmful ingredients in your daily products.

Questions

Quick answers.

Is Blistex actually medicated?
Blistex Medicated Lip Balm contains menthol and camphor as 'active ingredients,' but these are irritants that create a tingling sensation rather than truly treating lip problems. They can actually worsen chronic lip dryness. Numbrrrz contains genuinely nourishing organic ingredients that repair rather than irritate.
Why does Blistex make my lips feel worse?
The menthol and camphor in Blistex irritate lip tissue, causing a cycle of temporary relief followed by increased dryness. This drives you to reapply constantly. Switching to Numbrrrz breaks this cycle — your lips may feel a bit dry for the first few days as they adjust, but will be significantly healthier within a week.
Do I need a medicated lip balm or is Numbrrrz enough?
For everyday lip dryness, chapping, and weather damage, Numbrrrz is all you need. Medicated lip balms are generally only warranted for specific medical conditions diagnosed by a dermatologist. For normal lip care, the irritants in medicated balms do more harm than good.
What chemicals are in Blistex lip balm?
Blistex Medicated Lip Balm contains dimethicone, menthol, camphor, methylparaben, propylparaben, petrolatum, mineral oil, cyclomethicone, FD&C Red 40 dye, saccharin, and over a dozen other synthetic compounds. It is one of the most chemically complex lip balms on the market. Numbrrrz uses four ingredients total, all of which you can easily identify and understand.
Is Blistex cruelty-free?
Blistex does not carry Leaping Bunny certification and has not made a clear public commitment to ending animal testing. Their animal testing policies remain unclear. Numbrrrz is cruelty-free — we do not test on animals and never will.
What is a good clean alternative to Blistex?
Numbrrrz is the ideal clean alternative for Blistex users who want effective lip care without medicated irritants, silicones, parabens, and artificial dyes. Our four organic ingredients — Organic Coconut Oil, Organic Jojoba Oil, Organic Beeswax, and Vitamin E — address lip dryness at the root rather than masking it with a chemical tingle.
Ready to make the switch?

Upgrade to clean.

Join thousands who’ve switched to organic lip care.